Releasing from the CAF this year? CAF pay, a new job and a pension transfer value can all land on the same tax return, each withheld on its own. What to expect at tax time and how to plan for a possible balance owing.

It’s your final day. You’ve returned your kit, signed back in all your equipment and worked through roughly five thousand check-out steps to get every box ticked on your clearance card. It feels a bit familiar, since you’ve done this same rigmarole every time you posted in or out of a base, but this time is different. It feels more permanent.
You’re at work in civvies because the uniform is already gone, and you aren’t really working the way you used to. Everyone is moving around you and you feel like you should be doing something, but every time you try, you get rebuffed. Your coworkers tell you to bugger off and your supervisors just tell you to finish your process.
At the transition centre (maybe you were already there a few weeks ago), they hand you your veteran card and a stack of papers to sign. None of it is unusual, but somewhere among the thousands of documents you’ve signed is your pension option decision. Immediate annuity, if you’re eligible? Transfer value (TV)? Deferred annuity? Or, in some cases, a return of contributions.
You’ve heard the stories about people taking the TV and getting hit with a surprise bill at tax time. But you’re starting a new job, so you figure taxes will be taken care of there. Or maybe you’re taking some time off, going back to school, or releasing on medical grounds. Each of these changes what you can and can’t claim and what your tax picture looks like.
Most people assume their taxes are paid by year end. In a typical year as a serving member with T4 income only, that’s usually true. You file and get a refund, or maybe a small balance owing.
The release year is different. You get to the part of the return where you’re used to seeing a refund, and this time the balance owing is in the thousands. The first thought is usually “what did I do wrong?”
Most likely, nothing. It’s just the first time in years you’ve had to think about it, and a few things changed at once.
CAF pay continues until your release date, and your last regular pay normally lands about one to two weeks after your last day. After that, it takes some time for the CAF to confirm your pay file is up to date, and you may see some small adjustments once it is. Occasionally something is owed back (missing equipment, for example), but that’s case by case. You’ll also likely keep receiving pay statements for about six months, even though most will show no income.
Separately, lump sums can show up months or even years after release, like a benefit you were eligible for but never received while serving, or a retroactive pay increase covering one or more of the years you served. They count as income in the year they’re paid, so one landing in your release year adds to an already heavier year, and one arriving later can catch you off guard in a year you thought was simple. Either way, these go to the account on file, so don’t change or close bank accounts too quickly after release.
If you start a new job right away, that employer withholds tax based only on what they’re paying you. They usually assume that salary is all you’ll earn for the year, sometimes adjusted for the months remaining, sometimes not. They don’t know about your CAF income. Once your CAF pay and new salary are added together on your return, your total income can land in a higher bracket than either employer withheld for, and the difference shows up as a balance owing.
Most members don’t catch this during the year. They find out when they file.
The pension decision usually involves the biggest number of the year.
With the deferred annuity, you stop contributing and receive a guaranteed monthly pension once you reach eligibility age. Your service and salary are fixed at the point of release, so the amount is lower than what a member with 25 years receives as an immediate annuity, or what members released under certain medical provisions receive.
With the TV, you receive the value of your pension now and manage it yourself. You choose your investments, but the locked-in portion has to stay locked in, with some exceptions. That portion goes into a tax-sheltered locked-in account and doesn’t affect your taxes. Anything above the prescribed transfer limit is paid out to you as an unlocked portion, and that portion is treated as income.
You can use the unlocked portion for whatever you need. For some people it makes sense to pay down high-interest debt, put it toward a home or a business, or hold it as a cushion while looking for work. Keep in mind the TV takes time to arrive: roughly 30 to 60 days after all the paperwork is received and confirmed, or after your release date, whichever is later.
The unlocked portion is usually more than $15,000, so 30% is typically withheld at source. Smaller amounts are withheld at a lower rate, which can leave an even bigger gap at tax time. Many members don’t expect any withholding at all, so this comes as a surprise. It actually works in your favour, because it keeps the bill from getting worse. It doesn’t solve everything, though. Your CAF income, your new job’s income and the unlocked portion all go on the same return. When your combined federal and provincial marginal rate is higher than the rate withheld, you can still owe, especially if your new employer is also under-withholding.
The good news is that this can be managed. If you have RRSP room, you can put the unlocked portion into an RRSP. That has two effects. The deduction offsets the income from the payout, and the money stays invested and working for you instead of going to a tax bill that earns you nothing. Keep in mind it’s a deferral, though. Whatever you take out of the RRSP later counts as income in the year you withdraw it and is taxed at your marginal rate then, which works best in a lower-income year.
The same idea applies to employment income. RRSP or First Home Savings Account (FHSA) contributions reduce your taxable income, or you can ask your new employer to temporarily withhold more.
To get a rough sense of where you stand, add up three numbers: your year-to-date CAF earnings, the unlocked portion of your TV, and what you expect to earn (gross) at your new job by year end. Run that total through an online income tax calculator. Then subtract what’s already been withheld. Your CAF statement shows year-to-date tax withheld, and the difference between the unlocked amount paid out and what you actually received is the amount held back. What’s left is a ballpark of what you might owe, before tax withheld at the new job and any credits or deductions.
You’ve hit 25 years and your pension starts right away. The year has CAF pay up to your release date and pension payments after it, plus anything from a new job if you start one. The pension centre withholds based on the pension alone, and your new employer withholds based on your new salary alone, so the combined income can land in a higher bracket than either one accounted for. Your CAF pension can be split with a spouse, which can take some of the edge off.
You’re releasing on medical grounds. Your monthly income may come from SISIP long-term disability (LTD) or from VAC’s Income Replacement Benefit (IRB), which replaces the income you can no longer earn because of a disability, rather than from your CAF pension. LTD and the IRB are both taxable. A VAC disability pension or pain and suffering compensation is tax-free, so knowing which one you’re receiving changes what goes on your return. Each payer only sees what it’s paying you, so the more taxable sources you have, the bigger the gap can get. If you’re also receiving your CAF pension, it can be split with a spouse.
You take the TV and start a new job a few weeks later. By December you have three sources of income: CAF pay, your new salary and the unlocked portion of the TV. Each was withheld as if it were the only one. This is the combination behind most of the surprise bills.
You take the TV and use it to start a business. The unlocked portion is taxed the same whether it goes into equipment or sits in the bank. Business income has nothing withheld, so whatever profit you make in the first few months adds to the balance owing. Setting up also means deciding on a structure (sole proprietorship, partnership or corporation), and some of the setup costs can be deductible. An accountant is worth having at this stage, and a lawyer too, depending on how complex the business is.
You defer your pension and start a new job. With no lump sum, it’s mostly the two-employer withholding issue. The bill is usually smaller and easier to head off by asking your new employer to withhold a bit more.
You take the TV and go back to school. Your income drops, but the release year still carries your CAF pay, the unlocked portion and any Education and Training Benefit (ETB) you receive. The ETB is taxable too, though the tuition tax credit on the program it pays for can offset part of the tax on it. The lower-income school years that follow can also work in your favour. You can put the unlocked portion into an RRSP now and hold the deduction for a higher-income year, or draw from the RRSP while you’re in school, when it’s taxed at a lower rate.
A CAF-funded move to your IPR follows the same process as any posting move, with roughly the same implications, including for selling a home. If you aren’t eligible for a funded move to your IPR, track all your moving expenses. Moving at least 40 km closer to a new job or full-time school can make those costs deductible. It isn’t as generous as a CAF move, but make sure it gets claimed, and let your accountant know.
The members who come through the release year well tend to have it planned out, and they ask for help when it’s more than they can handle on their own. If you have a lot going on, get a specialist involved early, whether that’s a financial planner, an accountant or both. Focus on what you’re good at, and don’t let pride be the thing that costs you.
Taxes are only one part of it. What most people underestimate is how strange it feels to be on the other side. There are no hard timelines and nobody depending on you in quite the same way, and you have far more control over your schedule, even working for someone else. The work ethic is different too, at school or at work. Not everyone is as committed to getting the mission done as you might be used to. It takes some getting used to.
There’s always a life after the military, and even while you’re serving, you can plan for your exit. Remembrance week is about those who served before us and those who gave the ultimate sacrifice. It’s also a good time to recognise your own contribution and plan for your future and your family’s, including making sure your family is set up to succeed if the worst happens. Nobody joins to be a martyr, but signing on the dotted line means giving up a substantial amount of your freedom. Don’t let that mean nothing.
Our Military Family Tax service covers release years, pension decisions and everything that comes with them. CAF members, veterans and their families save 15% on every service with a valid CF One card.